Today’s quick review: The Thin Man. When a scientist goes missing, his daughter Dorothy (Maureen O’Sullivan) implores Nick Charles (William Powell), a retired detective and a friend of the familiy, to locate him. Nick refuses at first, preferring to spend his retirement entertaing with his wife Nora (Myrna Loy). But when the missing scientist’s secretary is murdered, casting suspicion on him, Nick agrees to take the case.
The Thin Man is a classic crime comedy based on a novel by Dashiell Hammett. The film is a murder mystery with a comedic twist: Nick and Nora Charles are a pair of easygoing socialites who treat the case with the same nonchalance as everything else. William Powell and Myrna Loy make a fantastic couple, and their perpetual banter forms the core of the movie. They are backed by a witty script and a fairly involved mystery for a plot.
The Thin Man’s greatest draw is its leads. Nick and Nora Charles have a unique dynamic that makes them a delight to watch. Their relationship is built on booze, wit, and an unshakable, if largely unspoken, foundation of love and trust. Their friendly ribbing is the highlight of the film, a thoroughly enjoyable mixture of verbal sparring and cooperation. Their supporting cast complements them well, filling out the more serious roles in the plot.
The mystery side of the movie is generally satisfying, but it has a few drawbacks. Dorothy’s missing father makes for a strong plot hook, and his family and associates makes for a long list of suspects when the murdering starts. However, the film’s pacing is peculiar. Nick and Nora themselves are late to the party, and while the investigation goes through several stages, there are fewer twists than the lengthy setup would suggest.
The Thin Man is a refreshing blend of comedy and mystery, ably written and excellently performed. Its plot is a little less substantial than the usual noir fare, and its setup, though interesting, delays the arrival of its stars. But these factors are easy to overlook in favor of the movie’s substantial strengths, making The Thin Man a worthwhile watch for any fan of the classics. Skip it if you’re looking for blunt comedy, slapstick, or a tense thriller.
8.1 out of 10 on IMDB. I give it a 7.5 for a good plot and a phenomenal pair of leads.