Today’s quick review: Another Earth. Four years after her drunk driving killed a mother and child, Rhoda Williams (Brit Marling), a bright young woman, returns home from jail. Wracked with guilt, she takes a job cleaning for John Burroughs (William Mapother), the father who survived the crash, without telling him who she is. As the two work through their respective issues, the world marvels at a mirror Earth that appeared in the sky the night of the crash.
Another Earth is a budget science fiction drama that deals with themes of guilt, loss, and regret. Another Earth takes a close look at two lives affected by tragedy: the young woman responsible for the death of two innocents, and the man most affected by their loss. The movie’s sole sci-fi conceit is the mysterious appearance of another Earth in the sky, one that appears to be an exact copy of the familiar one.
Another Earth handles its drama well. Rhoda’s guilt, depression, and attempts at coping are all realistic, as are John’s. Another Earth captures countless little, significant moments that add up to a rich portrait of a tragedy. However, the films layers on its drama a little too thickly in places, and its few positive moments are not bright enough to cut through the film’s melancholy.
Another Earth makes limited use of its sci-fi elements. Earth 2 is a constant backdrop in the movie, but the questions it poses are largely rhetorical ones. Earth 2 exists primarily to prompt introspection in Rhoda, John, and humanity as a whole. The second planet has modest plot significance, but the focus remains on Rhoda and her troubles, not the larger questions of why the planet appeared or how interaction with it might play out.
Another Earth will most strongly appeal to fans of grounded, personal drama. Its rough production quality leaves something to be desired, but an insightful script and credible acting make it worthwhile for those interested in themes of guilt and depression. Skip it if you are looking for a light watch, or if you are a science fiction fan hoping to see contact with another planet. For marginally similar movies, check out Contact or Upside Down.
7.0 out of 10 on IMDB. I give it a 6.5 to 7.0 for well-handled drama, mixed production quality, and underused sci-fi elements.